High School

Find the mistake in the steps.

Q: $log_{0.2}(\frac{x+2}{x}) \le 1$, solve for x.

steps: $log_5(\frac{x+2}{x})^{-1} \le log_5 5$

$\frac{x}{x+2} \le 5$

$\frac{x-5x-10}{x+2} \le 0$

$(x+2)(-4x-10) \le 0$

Answer :

Let's examine the steps given in the problem and identify the mistake in solving the inequality.

  1. Initial Problem:
    [tex]\log_{0.2}\left(\frac{x+2}{x}\right) \le 1[/tex]

  2. Change of Base and Rewriting the Logarithm:
    The student attempts to rewrite the expression using a change of base:
    [tex]\log_{0.2} A = \frac{\log_5 A}{\log_5 0.2}[/tex]
    where [tex]A = \frac{x+2}{x}[/tex].

  3. Finding the Mistake:
    In the provided solution steps, instead of correctly changing the base of the logarithm, the student incorrectly applies a negation and changes the expression:

    • The original inequality was [tex]\log_{0.2}(\frac{x+2}{x}) \le 1[/tex],
    • It should have been converted to the same base without inversion or negation immediately: [tex]\log_5(\frac{x+2}{x}) \ge \log_5(0.2)[/tex].
    • The error starts where the log was negated and rewritten as: [tex]\log_5(\frac{x+2}{x})^{-1} \le \log_5 5[/tex].
  4. Correct Approach:
    Begin correctly changing the inequality according to logarithmic properties:
    Since [tex]0.2 = 5^{-1}[/tex],
    [tex]\log_{0.2}\left(\frac{x+2}{x}\right) = -\log_5\left(\frac{x+2}{x}\right)[/tex]
    Thus,
    [tex]-\log_5\left(\frac{x+2}{x}\right) \le 1[/tex]
    Multiplying both sides of the inequality by -1 (which reverses the inequality):
    [tex]\log_5\left(\frac{x+2}{x}\right) \ge -1[/tex]
    Therefore:
    [tex]\frac{x+2}{x} \ge 5^{-1} = \frac{1}{5}[/tex]

  5. Solving the Correct Inequality:
    [tex]\frac{x+2}{x} \ge \frac{1}{5}[/tex]
    Multiply both sides by [tex]5x[/tex] to clear the fraction:
    [tex]5(x+2) \ge x[/tex]
    [tex]5x + 10 \ge x[/tex]
    Rearrange:
    [tex]4x \ge -10[/tex]
    Divide by 4:
    [tex]x \ge -\frac{5}{2}[/tex]

Thus, the correct solution range for [tex]x[/tex] is [tex]x \ge -\frac{5}{2}[/tex]. The mistake was in the handling of logarithmic properties and incorrectly applying operations to the inequality.